Talk of the Gospel?

Last week, The Wall Street Journal published “The Forces That Messed With the GOP’s Grip on Texas.”1 Its opening puts a finger on the challenge facing American Christendom. Cameron Cushman, a conservative evangelical Christian, voted for James Talarico in the Democratic primary, then supported him again in November—his first vote for a Democrat in a statewide general election. The Journal reported that Cushman was moved by Talarico’s “talk of the Gospel.” Moved by his talk of the Gospel. But was the teaching Biblical? In his first epistle, 1 John, the Apostle John warns of “many antichrists,” identifying those who denied the Father and the Son (1 John 2:18–23). His specific description must not be carelessly applied. But the warning should awaken us: a profession of Christianity places no one’s teaching beyond examination. Government orders closing churches during COVID-19 put the confrontation in plain sight. A familiar voice from a pulpit, quoting Scripture with warmth and conviction before a national audience, may find the door wide open. In Gleanings in Joshua, A.W. Pink contrasts Satan’s open opposition as a roaring lion with his covert work as a subtle serpent. Persecution puts Christians on guard. Deception gains entrance by appearing trustworthy. It arrives with credentials, persuasive language, and institutional approval. Having forfeited so much of our Judeo-Christian heritage and the Biblical foundations of our culture, do we still possess the Biblical knowledge to recognize it? For the last generation, the Church has braced for the lion’s roar: government restrictions, legal penalties, and demands that Christians violate their conscience. Three examples bring the battle into focus: Jack Phillips, Masterpiece Cakeshop, Colorado. After Phillips declined to create a cake for a same-sex wedding, Colorado’s Civil Rights Commission ruled against him. In 2018, the Supreme Court ruled 7–2 in his favor, finding that the state had failed to treat his religious beliefs with constitutionally required neutrality. Coach Joe Kennedy, Bremerton, Washington. His postgame prayers became a legal battle with his school district. In 2022, the Supreme Court ruled 6–3 that the district had violated his rights to free speech and the free exercise of religion. Pastor Ché Ahn, Harvest Rock Church, Pasadena, California. Ahn and his congregation faced threatened criminal penalties for gathering to worship during California’s COVID restrictions. They stood their ground. Their legal battle ended in a 2021 settlement and permanent injunction against discriminatory restrictions on worship gatherings. Under Governor Gavin Newsom’s edicts, liquor stores and marijuana dispensaries remained open while churches were barred from gathering indoors—a revealing measure of what he considered “essential.” Keep that in mind when weighing his fitness for higher office. Space prevents recounting the battles of Barronelle Stutzman, Lorie Smith, the Little Sisters of the Poor, Catholic Social Services, the Houston pastors, Kelvin Cochran, and John MacArthur’s Grace Community Church. Those conflicts required Christians to recognize government overreach, resist it, and stand firm. Politicians invoking Christianity demand equally vigilant examination: Is their teaching faithful to the infallible Word? Let’s cut to the chase. On November 3, Texas elected Presbyterian seminarian James Talarico to the United States Senate. Kansas elected Adam Hamilton, pastor of America’s largest United Methodist congregation. Both made Christian faith central to their appeal for office. Both speak fluent Christianese. We do not claim to read their hearts. We are called to weigh their words against the Word. Senator-elect Talarico frequently invokes Scripture, yet he has told national audiences that “Jesus never talks about abortion” and that “the Bible is silent on abortion.” He has also blustered that “God is non-binary”—language he subsequently acknowledged was provocative. These claims are made in Scripture’s name and must be examined under Scripture’s authority. The absence of an explicit recorded statement by Jesus about abortion does not settle what the Bible teaches about unborn life. Scripture describes God knitting us together in our mothers’ wombs (Psalm 139:13) and John leaping in Elizabeth’s womb in the presence of Christ (Luke 1:41). Talarico must account for those passages while evangelizing his claim that the Bible is silent on abortion. Hamilton has led Church of the Resurrection for more than three decades. He also became a prominent advocate for changing his denomination’s restrictions on same-sex weddings and gay clergy—restrictions removed in 2024. His advocacy came through sermons, conferences, and—of all things—appeals to Christian faithfulness. With their national megaphones and growing prominence as “Christian leaders,” these men will reach many in our flocks. Shepherds must equip their parishioners to distinguish persuasive delivery from faithful exposition. Sincerity cannot substitute for submission to Scripture. Israel’s leaders examined the Gibeonites’ provisions but “asked not counsel at the mouth of the LORD” (Joshua 9:14). They inspected the evidence placed before them and accepted the story. The Church must learn from their failure. Impressive appearances do not relieve us of the responsibility to seek God’s counsel. As we close, consider Michael V. Fox’s discussion of Proverbs 17:11 in his Anchor Yale Bible commentary. The Jewish scholar observes that the messenger sent against the rebel may be human or angelic. Drawing on Saadia Gaon, Fox explains that rebellion against an earthly king brings an earthly officer to execute judgment. But “if he rebels against God’s Word, punitive angels are dispatched.” As we enter this new season, American Christendom must remain vigilant toward the serpent’s subtlety as we distinguish Christian language from faithfulness to Christ. A national platform does not confer spiritual authority; neither does an election victory. When Scripture is invoked to justify what Scripture condemns, shepherds must open their Bibles, equip their flocks, find their voices—and move into the public square. White evangelicals accounted for 17% of November’s electorate. When we stay home, the other side elects its candidates—who then draft legislation, pass it, and write their values into law. Please, God, bring a Gideon or Rahab to make a stand. David Lane American Renewal Project [1] “The Forces That Messed With the GOP’s Grip on Texas,” The Wall Street Journal |





Comments